Saturday, August 9, 2014

August 9: Sorcerer (1977 -- William Friedkin)

★★★

If this had turned out to be the film that Friedkin intended, it would have been fantastic.  Unfortunately, Sorcerer has many problems, and the coup de grâce is that it never approaches the quality of Clouzot’s cover of the same material, The Wages of Fear.

In Clouzot’s tight film, the opening section sets up a world whose values inform the subsequent road adventures.  These values – pessimism, opportunism, amorality -- heighten the suspense as well as give us an investment in the characters.  Friedkin might have been trying to do the same in the opening section of Sorcerer, but the film rambles into a two-stage opening that neither creates a sustained mood nor establishes characters that we care much about.  In the first stage, we meet the characters on their individual home turfs as assassins, robbers, terrorists and con artists; after this extended section on four continents, we then see these characters for a while in a small, Latin village.  This extended introductory section of the movie has so much sprawl that we have no time to connect with any of the quartet; worse still, the information in this section is only modestly important later in the film.  While we eventually have the Palestinian bomber, Kassim, blowing a fallen tree out of the road, the Frenchman Victor’s fraud is irrelevant to the rest of the film, we learn so little of Latin Nilo in the intro that he’s even hard to recognize when he arrives in the village, and the calm efficiency we see of the American Jackie in the introduction has little take up in the rest of the film.  It feels as if Friedkin is aiming to recreate the pervasive existentialism of Clouzot’s opening, but Sorcerer instead gives us a long, diffuse introduction to some bad guys who inhabit a world that isn’t necessarily corrupt.

When the trucks finally get rolling, so does Sorcerer.  While there are several fine action and thrill scenes in the film, the best by far is the scene of the trucks crossing the rope bridge in a storm.  As the trucks lurch and lean, it’s only the most jaded of viewers who won’t gasp and wonder how Friedkin created the effects.  But such action sequences aside, the other elements of the film are sour here.  We are most attached to Victor through the introductory section, but his role is diminished in the travel section; conversely, the man we see the least in the introduction, Nilo, becomes one of the most important characters on the trip.  As Nilo becomes the coward we recall in Clouzot’s Jo, we are far less disgusted here because we don’t know much about him and we don’t see the hypocritical contrast between the gangster poseur and scared weakling Nilo soon becomes.  And one of the strangest transformations is when a shot of the grimly determined Jackie cuts to a shot of Jackie having a hallucinatory nervous breakdown.  And that in a desert that has suddenly replaced the rain forest.  Such contrastive cuts can have an effective role, but in a film that doesn’t use this technique for the first two hours of narrative, it feels more like bad film-making than innovative styling.

Friedkin’s ambitions are evident here -- grand existentialist statement, explicit anti-Americanism, intertextuality with his earlier Exorcist success (witness the title, flashes to pre-Colombian masks, and the menacing grill of one of the trucks).  But Friedkin’s failure to focus and his lack of control prevents Sorcerer from delivering on any of them, and there’s not even enough excess to provide the kind of pleasure we might get from a similar effort by a director like Herzog.  Sorcerer delivers us some grand action scenes in the middle of muddle that neither achieves the profundity it aspires to nor satisfies our desire for a tight aesthetic experience.

Thursday, August 7, 2014

August 7: The Wages of Fear/Le salaire de la peur (1953 -- Georges Clouzot)

★★★★★

This movie just keeps thrilling.  Deservedly famed for its suspense, Wages of Fear doesn't draw on sudden surprises and camera cheats.  Instead, its bleak, existential world wrings out of us all hope of anything good happening to the characters, and we expect its world of material determinism to ultimately punish the quartet of risk-takers at the center of the film.  After the happy achievement of the men blowing up a boulder that had blocked the road, a rock that was dislodged by the explosion tumbles down the hill toward a jerry can filled with nitro.  Given the world of the film, we don’t really know whether or not the rock will hit the can and destroy the men and their trucks.  In this case, it doesn't, but later in the film, a happy achievement will be quickly followed by a devastating one.  Because the world of Wages of Fear is so bleak, we watch it in continuing expectation of something bad happening.

Many elements of Wages of Fear create this world, but the oft-criticized, but its long set-up is one of the most important.  Love, friendship, fairness, honesty, and decency have a place in this world as a group of expats jockey with each other for advantage.  In the opening of the film, we see kids playing with roaches whose legs are tied together, a bleak symbol of the world here (and one Peckinpah references at the opening of The Wild Bunch).  We soon see Mario mistreating Linda and pragmatically shifting his friendship from Luigi to Jo.  Meanwhile, Linda’s boss uses her sexually, and flaunts it to Mario, while she sees her situation as part of the deal.  The unscrupulous O’Brien won’t help his former friend Jo and recruits expats for the suicide job of transporting the nitro because they're so readily expendable.  The situation is so bleak that the despairing Italian kid hangs himself…at a shrine to the Virgin.  Introduced to a world like this, we don’t expect happy things to occur when the men finally take to the road, so we watch, expecting the worst at any moment.

The existential emptiness here becomes more obvious later.  Age, in the character of Jo, has neither wisdom nor respect.  Despite all his tough guy posturing early in the film, Jo is stricken sick with fear as they start transporting the nitro and is later beaten by the younger Mario, who explicitly says physical strength shouldn't be a determiner but is.  Injured and reminiscing about a high fence he’d never looked behind as a kid, Jo dies saying “there’s nothing there,” a somewhat on-the-nose summary of the film's philosophy.  And after we get to know the amiable Luigi and Bimba, Clouzot kills them in an explosion we don’t even see.  A flash of light interrupts the conversation of Jo and Mario, and we hear an explosion.  Clouzot then cuts to a column of smoke in the distance.  There’s no drama or heroic struggle when we lose that truck; instead, the two men just vanish without meaning or significance.

The bleakness, which creates so much of the suspense of the film, is not without its moments of beauty.  At one point, Clouzot’s camera captures a family of rainforest Indians watching the oil well burn, and there’s memorable beauty in the oil-filled crater left by the truck explosion; the rhythmical pumping of oil from the pipeline is like a heartbeat as gushes of black oil slowly fill the crater.  It’s the ruptured artery of the film’s dark world.  And there’s a strong, graphic shot of Mario looking at the lattice of beams holding up the turn-around platform on a curve of the road.  The beams cast an imprisoning shadow over Mario as he walks around outside the platform.  With the help of cinematographer Armand Thirard, Clouzot manages to find dark beauty in Wages of Fear.

This film is a bleak thriller that gets no small part of its life from its pessimistic worldview.  Hitchcock may thrill with bravura, panache and psychology, but as Wages of Fear shows, Clouzot can thrill with philosophy.

Sunday, August 3, 2014

August 3: Insomnia (1997 -- Erik Skjoldbjærg)

★★★★

Here is an unusual, engaging crime procedural that depends way more on atmosphere and psychology than on the case details that are slowly revealed to us.  Insomnia’s cinematography creates a world of flat, unexceptional interiors made of the mundane, baseboard heating and spare, functional furnishings.  The film’s high key lighting banishes shadows and contributes to the sense that the light in this town of the midnight sun fills every space.  And when when we're in Insomnia’s bright, flat interiors, every window shows us a burned out exterior where the light is so strong that no detail is visible.  The light in this film is a character, and it is an important factor in the increasing psychosis of the chief investigator, Jonas Engström.

From the time our we first meet Engström, we have the sense there is something wrong.  He’s on a plane with Erik Vik, his fellow investigator, when the pilot announces they've crossed the Arctic Circle.  The dozing Vik rouses a bit, and then we hear the exact same announcement again, as though Engström’s mind has momentarily slipped a notch, missed some information, or lapsed into a daydream.  It's not clear exactly what happens here, but we quickly realize that Engström’s mind is working in a way slightly different from ours.

We’re soon following the sleepless Engström as he tries to solve the murder of Tanja but accidentally shoots Vic.  The detective then begins to build a web of lies to frame Tanja's murderer, Jon Holt, for Vic’s death, but the lies becomes more and more complicated, and Engström finds himself both the object of a police investigation and victim of blackmail by Holt.  And as Engström increasingly struggles to create a coherent story to account for the facts, director Erik Skjoldbjærg also mixes in a couple of uncomfortable scenes charged with sexual energy between Engström and local women.  And all the while, Engström is unable to sleep because of the harsh, omnipresent light in Tromsø, and his psychology, fragile at the beginning of the film, shows more and more signs of strain.

Skjoldbjærg's achievement here is that the details of the crime are not the focus of interest in Insomnia. Instead, we have an edgy, fascinating, detective improvising an increasingly complex and increasingly high stakes network of lies while he is on the verge of cracking in this environment that would stress even a sane person.  And that is what we watch with fascination.

Monday, July 21, 2014

July 21: Jodorowsky’s Dune (2013 -- Frank Pavich)

★★★

Formally, Jodorowsky's Dune is a fairly conventional documentary.  It’s mostly a series of talking heads, though the animation from the detailed storyboards of the script certainly helps us get a modest feel for what the project might have looked like.  And though it’s hard to imagine another structure, the predictability of the film’s progress becomes somewhat boring.  We go from Alejandro Jodorowsky’s work before this project to a very long list of big-name people he got involved to a conclusion of the ripple effects of the project.  The form here isn’t what engages.

Instead, it’s the vision and audacity of Jodorowsky that keeps us in the film.  Jodorowsky was immersed in the cultural currents of the late 60s/early 70s.  From absurdist theater, we went on to make two wildly experimental films, and his Dune was to  be based on what he wanted to talk about – the expansion of consciousness – rather than the contents of Herbert’s work.  One of a couple of the self-referential aspects of this story shows how director Jodorowsky essentially became a prophet, like Paul of the novel, stimulating the disciples he recruited for the project to open their minds.  And we can note the ongoing effect of Jodorowsky's teaching in the subsequent careers of figures like HR Giger, Dan O’Bannon and Chris Foss.  Jodorowsky pulled these creative artists into film, and they all went on to make important contributions arising, in part, from the way Jodorowsky developed their talent.

There is a lot of Entertainment Tonight in the overlong middle section of the film as we hear funny stories about Jodorowsky’s encounter with Pink Floyd, Dalí, Jagger, David Carradine, and Welles.  But the range of Jodorowsky’s contacts, the countries he worked in, and the areas of 70s pop culture he mined are a fascinating look into that era and into some of the cultural trends at work.  Jodorowsky lived at the nexus of those trends at that time, and part of the pleasure of Jodorowsky's Dune is to participate in that moment.

This film also makes the worthwhile observation that Jodorowsky's version of Dune became seminal to an important part of future sci fi cinema.  Like Paul’s death in Dune leads to the fertilization of the entire planet of Dune, so did the failure of Jodorowsky’s Dune lead to a dispersion of talent that went on to fertilize many important sci fi projects.  We see the echoes of Jodorowsky’s Dune in Star Wars, Alien, Prometheus, and Blade Runner among many important sci fi movies.  And it’s not that Lucas or Scott stole ideas from Jodorowsky but that the talent that worked on those later projects developed its vision from Jodorowsky’s prophetic leadership. 

It’s in describing this relationship that the important value, and pleasure, of Jodorowsky’s Dune lies.


Tuesday, July 1, 2014

July 1: The Freshman (1925 -- Fred C. Newmeyer & Sam Taylor)

★★★★

In a time that filmmakers would use melodrama to engage its audience, Lloyd created one of his most affective films in The Freshman.  It’s impossible not to empathize with Harold Lamb here.  The freshman is an archetypal American figure: optimistic, determined, and naïve.  Set upon becoming the Big Man on Campus, the hard-working Harold soon finds himself being abused by a jaded clique of college students who fake their like for him in order to trick him into using his limited money to buy them ice cream and sponsor a party.  Because of his naiveté, Harold doesn’t realize the ruse as they laugh at his jokes, imitate him, and pursue him to dance with; in fact, the group is mocking him to his very face in all these situations.  As Harold obliviously allows himself to be used by these people, our sympathy for him builds, stoked even further by comic misadventures like his unraveling suit and his role as the tackle dummy at football practice.  Our involvement climaxes when the angry Cad reveals the ruse to Harold, who tries to keep on a brave face before he breaks down into tears.  It’s inconceivable that Harold Lloyd at one time wanted to delete the crying scene from the film since this is the moment of our most intense involvement with the character.

The big ending of The Freshman has its own hooks.  Credit much of the success of this concluding episode to Pat Harmon as the Football Coach.  Harmon’s Coach is a bull of a man, prone to very physical expressions of his emotions like throwing his hands in the air, running in circles and bending over as if to beat the earth itself.  As his bench gets slimmer, the bad-tempered, stubborn man adamantly refuses to let Harold play even as the clock is running out and the refs are telling him he’ll have to forfeit.  His players can’t convince him to run Harold in and, as he fusses and fumes on the sidelines, Harmon takes the tension in the film to a new peak.  The Coach is also responsible for one last cruel joke on Harold, sending the eager sub in only to change sweaters with one of the other players.

But Harold finally gets to play, and as the seconds tick away, he almost saves the game and then quickly loses it again, with intercuts to the Coach’s sideline reactions building pressure at each shift and getting us more invested in the action.  Of course, this is a comedy and Harold is ultimately able to pull off a victory for Tate thanks to the same determination and optimism he brought to the school at the beginning of the film.  And he gets the girl.  But we've been put though an emotion ringer in getting there.

It’s The Freshman’s engagement with the audience that makes this comedy so strong.  The humor is cute, but it also develops the character and adds to the audience’s involvement in what’s happening.  If Lloyd's films break down in “thrill” and “character” categories, The Freshman is clearly in the latter.  The personality of Lloyd’s Harold is the spring that drives this movie and that keeps us in it.


Monday, June 30, 2014

June 30: Safety Last! (1923 -- Fred C. Newmeyer & Sam Taylor)

★★★★

Safety Last! is my first feature with Lloyd, and I see the appeal.  His Glasses Boy is as cute as a button and as animated as a Disney creation.  Lloyd seems to mine every moment of Safety Last! for its comic potential, whether he’s trying to get to work on time, waiting on ladies in the fabric department of a department store or climbing the façade of the Bolton Building.  His humor is sometimes more like that of the Three Stooges than of Chaplin or Keaton: Jackets get ripped up the back, people get kicked in the butt when they bend over, and witless police are continually outfoxed in pursuit of their suspect.  But despite the hooey that calls on us to suspend disbelief when Lloyd takes over his boss’ office and pushes buttons to call assistants, Lloyd’s screen presence has a charm that makes us willing to play along.

Part of the Boy’s charm here is his basic goodness.  He wants to bring his girlfriend to the city, so goes off in earnest to make money.  He wants to do well at work, help out his friend, and succeed, but he never tries to advance by stepping on others.  With his fresh face and sincerity of character, he’s a hard man not to like.

His comedy also has an engaging, agile physicality.  We watch him brushing aside pigeons while he clings to the side of a building, and we see him hook his foot through a looped rope and become a human pendulum when he falls.  He jumps from a bus and into a car.  And even less dramatic moments of his comedy rely on his supple dexterity.  At one point, he wraps himself up in a mannequin to get into De Vore’s unobserved, and he then folds himself into a human crab to walk to his post unobserved.

And Safety Last! builds itself into something close to an action thriller in its last, extended skit.  The Boy climbs the Bolton Building one story at a time, at each floor expecting his human fly pal, Bill, to replace him.  The friend, though, is unrelentingly pursued by the policeman and has to flee at each floor just as the Boy gets there.  And the Boy also encounters an obstacle at each floor, from an over-large large ledge to a volleyball net, pigeons, office workers and even a fussy grandmother.  And the famous clock.  Tension builds steadily as we watch the Boy’s danger increase and his hope of salvation retreat.

Safety Last! is a fun movie.  Some of the gags are forced – and even stupid – but that's to be expected in such an intense concentration of humor.  The film is nonetheless fun, energetic and far more inventive than many other comedies.


Sunday, June 22, 2014

June 22: To Be or Not to Be (1942 -- Ernst Lubitsch)

★★★★★

Controversial at the time, Ernst Lubitsch’s strategy of fighting fascism with wit and finesse led to one of his most effective works in To Be or Not to Be.  Lubitsch’s cinematic strength isn't drama, adventure or broad comedy, so when wanted to take aim at what was happening in Europe, he applied his Lubitsch Touch to deflate National Socialism rather than confront it.

The witty layers that are so important to the film are apparent from the opening, which is as bravura an opening as any Indiana Jones faced.  The film starts with Hitler window shopping on a street in Warsaw and then cuts to a scene in a Gestapo office.  Aside from the Nazi connection, little binds these two shots, but the Gestapo scene is interrupted by yet a third narrative line that tells us the Gestapo office interaction isn't real but is part of a play.  With this new layer of information, the audience reinterprets the office scene as a piece of performance rather than the story of the film.  Meanwhile, the director of the play becomes involved in a discussion of the scene, which reveals that the Hitler we originally saw on the Warsaw street was actually one of these actors dressed as Hitler.  So we add a new layer of meaning to that first scene, and To Be or Not to Be then returns to it as the actor tries to prove he’s a convincing Hitler.  This four-part opening is a skilled, zippy run through several frames of reference that reinterpret and add layers of meaning to what we have in front of us onscreen.

And this opening is a microcosm of how Lubitsch uses complex, multiple layers of reinterpretation and meaning throughout the movie, usually to humorous effect and often at the expense of the Nazis.  When Joseph is impersonating Col. Ehrhardt with Siletsky, for example, the Professor jokes that Maria Tura’s husband was being fooled, and “Col. Ehrhardt” immediately moves to correct the situation because he is, in fact, Joseph.  It’s the reaction of a husband in the role of a Gestapo official, and we follow the scene on two levels.  This same scene sets up another example of layering.  During their conversation, Siletsky tells “Ehrhart” that he’s known as Concentration Camp Erhart, and Joseph/Ehrhart, unsure how to respond, replies “Ah, is that so”?  Later, when Joseph is playing Siletsky with the real Ehrhardt and tells the Colonel about the nickname, Ehrhart replies exactly as Joseph had previously. This response is an obvious ironic nod to the previous encounter, but Joseph’s multi-layered follow-up is that he’d thought Ehrhart would react that way, an appropriate comment in the immediate situation but also one that harkens back to the previous scene.  And even in small gestures, Lubitsch provides multiple layers of meaning.  As Joseph walks sadly into Maria’s dressing room after the announcement of the invasion of Poland, we assume he is sad over the news; in fact, he’s sad because someone has walked out of his performance.  Added to the irony of the two interpretations of Joseph’s sadness is that Maria had set up the walk-out for her own purposes.  To Be or Not to Be spends much of its run time building multiple layers of meaning for scenes.

And if the opening of the film is a preview of Lubitsch’s use of multi-layered significance, it also points to how tightly To Be or Not to Be is constructed.  Detail after detail in the opening is picked up later in the film.  Joseph’s jealousy of Maria becomes clear in some of the dialog of the opening, and it is very important later when the jealous husband accidentally reveals his identity to Siletsky.  And Bronsky’s portrayal of Hitler, which we see in the opening, becomes important in the escape scene later; there is also humorous reference several times to the scene stealing of Rawich, starting in the opening.  It is also in the opening that we first hear Greenberg refer to Shylock’s if-you-prick-us monologue, a monologue that takes on great, multi-layered pathos when the Jewish Greenberg delivers it to Hitler’s guard at the theater.  Even the joke in the opening about Hitler being remembered as a type of cheese resurfaces several times in the rest of the film.

The tightness of the introduction is only a foretaste of a script that wastes no detail.  For example, a reference to Joseph’s losing his fake beard and having a spare one becomes important when the actor has to shave the dead Siletsky’s face and use the spare on it.  And in fact, as the group is making its escape, Joseph again loses his beard.  Likewise, Hamlet’s to-be-or-not-to-be soliloquy has multiple uses throughout the film.  Originally a signal for Stanislav to come to Maria’s dressing room, it becomes a code that Stanislav uses to send a message to Maria.  And there’s the unexpected humor at the end of film when Joseph begins his soliloquy with Stanislav in the audience and, instead of Stanislav using it as cue to leave the audience, yet another soldier stands and makes his way out, surprising both of the men.  Details have functions in this tight script.

To Be or Not to Be sparkles with wit and economy.  A basic decision like casting Jack Benny as a Shakespearean actor carries no small amount of ironic wit, and when Benny walks on the stage as an old, tights-wearing Hamlet, the image is comic in itself.  There’s wit everywhere in the dialog, too.  “Does the fact that I can drop two tons of dynamite in three minutes interest you?” asks the young, sincere, smitten Stanslav.  “It CERTAINLY DOES!” leers Maria, playing with a double entendre.  There’s hardly a moment of the film that isn’t showing its wit or setting up a clever moment for later in the film.

But To Be or Not to Be isn’t all frothy comedy; Lubitsch lets the brutality of National Socialism show through clearly at points.  The film opens by showing the store signs of businesses in Warsaw, but after the Nazi conquest, we see the same signs fallen, broken and burned.  There’s no clever wit in these images.  Nor is the delivery by Greenberg of Shylock’s if-you-prick-us monologue a witty joke.  As the Jew stands in front of Hitler’s guard, the camera zooms in on his face, and the movie pauses to hear the Shakespearean anti-racist plea.  In context, it’s a plea for Poles, but the actor’s Jewish identity makes it also a plea for that persecuted minority.  We also see the reality of death in the macabre scene when Joseph finds himself, impersonating Siletsky, in the same room with the real Siletsky’s body.  Although the film is justly praised for its light Lubitsch Touch, there’s more than a little of the reality of the horrors of Nazism in the film.

It’s not hard to see the influence of To Be or Not to Be on Wes Anderson’s recent Grand Budapest Hotel.  Both films are articulate and witty, and both use this elegance in a critique of Nazism.  Gustave H. with his elaborate schemes and witty repartee would not be out of place in the world of To Be or Not to Be.  And in both films, there is also a brutality that occasionally jags through the comic artifice to remind us we’re not watching a film that is simply an ornate confection.  The brutal murder of  Vilmos Kovacs in Grand Budapest keeps the real subject of the film before us.  Overall, the common inspiration of the two films is striking.


To Be or Not to Be is an elegant, clever set of parallels, wit and layered meanings, but all this is in service of a deep critique of the horror that was already gripping Europe.  It’s no small task to pull such disparate elements together; it takes comprehensive vision and the touch of a director like Ernst Lubitsch.